Illusion of Life Analysis on 45 by Gaslight Anthem


The retail store I work at (Sportchek) generally plays a mixture of pump-up songs aiming to make the gym-buff buy more muscle shirts, the hockey player amped to practice with his new stick, and the golfer to ready to feel his swing in the golf course simulator. This is a portion of Sportchek’s advertising scheme aimed to get customers excited while in the store. But then I heard 45 by Gaslight Anthem and wondered if the gym-buffs, hockey players and golfers that were shopping knew the true meaning of the song. I didn’t really notice the darkness of the lyrics at first because of the upbeat nature of the song itself, but after I heard it a couple more times I began to think of the dynamic interaction between virtual experience and virtual time; first about the lyrics, secondly about the music, and lastly about the incongruence between the two in this particular song.

The story within the lyrics focuses on the familiar story of a man who lost the love of his life and has to deal with his loneliness, his friend’s [sometime’s harsh] opinions, and his past. You can tell already that he is angry in the first line, “Have you seen my hands, just look at ’em shake” and catch glimpses of the pain he has for his lover by the end of the first verse. Following the chorus, it starts to dig deep into his true feelings, “The tick, ticking of hours lonely… I hear the alarm. /I used to hear when she would sleep in my arms.” The songwriter also used an interesting form of dramatic illusion, which I think creates the sense of suspense-seeking resolution in the song that tends to represent intensity. The songwriter talks about the present and looking forward into the future, but it almost seems like a poetic illusion because he is stuck in his past, “And I dance with your ghost. But that ain’t the way…/I can’t move on and I can’t stay the same.”

A hard rock song such as this offers intense rhythms, loud phrasing, fast tempo, and full instrumentation. This song has a hearty rock n’ roll feel with a kick of country bass that is infectious. Its rhythmic structure has a driving tempo that is unpredictable. Its harmonic structure is stimulating and discordant, with a melodic structure that climbs sporadically with short-held tones. Its dynamics are disjointed and punched, and get louder and faster as the song progresses. Lastly, the song has many amplified instruments. All of these aspects of the song point to representative intensity in the musical elements.

Tragic lyrics paired up with an intensity musical pattern can have various effects on the listener. I think that in this case it is meant to inspire the listener to be strong after a break up; I think that the band wanted a song that could speak to people in a similar situation.The song also uses strategic ambiguity by not including any details of the ‘break up’, leaving listeners drawn to the song because they can theorize their own background stories. I know for a fact that if I would have listened to just the lyrics or just the music I would have a very different opinion on what message the song was trying to portray.

Ultimately, the emotional message of the lyrics and the conceptual message of the music contradict each other, making the lyrical and musical messages incongruent. I believe that the band chose to combine the two incongruent elements to create a lasting effect on the listener.



One thought on “Illusion of Life Analysis on 45 by Gaslight Anthem

  1. I think this is an excellent blog post! Even though I have honestly never heard of this band or song before, I can see why you chose this particular song for a Music analysis, and I think you did a great job! Before reading your blog, I watched the video just to see what it was about. The song is very catchy and it uses an amazing upbeat rhythm, with lots of rock and roll energy. I could immediately see the incongruity between the actual music and the lyrics upon reading them. I had no idea that this upbeat, energetic song could actually have such deep and meaningful lyrics!

    Your blog contains a clear thesis and your ideas are well thought out and organized. I particularly liked the depth you went to in describing the intensity and release patterns in the song! In fact, it almost felt like that section of your blog itself had its own rhythmic structure with really strong and engaging paragraphs supporting your thesis. I also really liked the fact that you mentioned that the song reflects both dramatic and poetic illusions to support your work.

    One thing I must note was that there was no mention of the target audience. According to Gonzalez and Makay, “music draws in listeners by using lyrical ascription and musical ascription” (Sellnow 122). Who do you think the target audience is? In your blog, you mention that the song is about a man who lost the love of his life, but does that necessarily mean that the love of his life left him? Or do you think she might have passed away? Also, you mention in the second paragraph that the speaker is angry as his hands are shaking. Although I agree that shaking hands can be a sign of anger, perhaps they might be from the remorse and frustration of losing something valuable from your life? You can also interpret the lyrics in an entirely different way. What if the speaker is a drug addict who has recently stopped using them and his “better sense” and friends are preventing him from abusing again? That could also explain why his hands are shaking. He could also be hallucinating about a girl- a mirage of the mental state he is in. The possibilities of interpretation are endless, but I think you should consider a variety of interpretations as the combination of the lyrics and the upbeat nature of the song draws in a particular target audience who can identify with the song itself.

    Another thing I’ve noticed is that you provided the music video, perhaps you can discuss that a bit too? How do you think it relates to the song itself? One thing I thought that was distinctive in the video is the image of a red picnic table- representing family and get-togethers, seen through a fence. Maybe there is a deeper meaning to that? I’ve also noticed that there are barely any colours seen throughout the video except the colours red and blue. The representations of these colours can be interpreted in various ways, so do go into a bit of detail regarding it if you can!

    Overall, I think you did an excellent job! Keep up the good work!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s